Colin Smyth MSP
Older People’s Commissioner Bill
Colin Smyth MSP’s Older People’s Commissioner Bill would allow a dedicated commissioner in Scotland to be established to ensure the voices of people in later life are heard.
The Commissioner would have the power to hold public bodies to account and take up issues on behalf of older people including carrying out inquiries into the adequacy of services for older people.
The independent commissioner would also have a key role to tackle age discrimination and ageism across Scottish society.
At present children and young people have standalone commissioners in each of the four nations of the UK, including Scotland, while Wales and Northern Ireland have commissioners for the older people.
The consultation for the Bill has now closed. You can view the responses below.
Responses from Organisations
ORG_001 Aberdeen City Health and Social Care Partnership (ID 227737223)
ORG_002 About Dementia (ID 229437701)
ORG_003 Ace It Scotland (ID 225261315)
ORG_004 Age Scotland (ID 229560656)
ORG_005 Argyll and Bute Health and Social Care Partnership (ID 229026379)
ORG_006 British Geriatrics Society (ID 228216007)
ORG_007 Carers Trust Scotland (ID 229574701)
ORG_008 Common Weal (non smart survey response)
ORG_009 Danderhall And Newton Retired – Ex Miners Branch (ID 229180753)
ORG_010 Equality and Human Rights Commission (non smart survey response)
ORG_011 Evangelical Alliance Scotland (ID 229462645)
ORG_012 Food Train Scotland(ID 228877049)
ORG_013 Free Church of Scotland (ID 229179489)
ORG_014 Fuel Poverty Action Scotland (ID 227180638)
ORG_015 Generations Working Together (ID 229705718)
ORG_016 Gullane Day Centre (ID 221708061)
ORG_017 Health and Social Care Alliance Scotland (ID 229518313)
ORG_018 Independent Age (ID 229463275)
ORG_019 Larkhall and District Volunteer Group (ID 222911351)
ORG_020 Law Society of Scotland (ID 229675253)
ORG_ 021 LifeCare Edinburgh Ltd (ID 224576758 )
ORG_022 Luminate (non smary survey response)
ORG_023 Obesity Action Scotland (non smart survey response)
ORG_024 Parkinson’s UK Scotland (ID 229706076)
ORG_025 Physiological Society (ID 228793753)
ORG_026 Roar-Connections For Life (ID 222269966)
ORG_027 Royal College of General Practitioners Scotland (ID 229672696)
ORG_028 Royal College of Nursing (ID 226094715)
ORG_029 Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh (ID 226917485)
ORG_030 Royal College of Psychiatrists in Scotland (ID 229708762)
ORG_031 Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (ID 229551889)
ORG_033 Scottish Care (ID 229712533)
ORG_035 Scottish Pensioners’ Forum
ORG_036 Sight Scotland and Sight Scotland Veterans Forum (229514039)
ORG_037 Social Work Scotland (ID 229683252)
ORG_038 St George’s and St Peter’s Community Association (ID222755768)
ORG_039 Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers (ID 229705455)
ORG_040 Vegeterian for Life (ID 229665742)
ORG_041 With You (ID 226155391)
Responses from Individuals
IND_A_001 Anonymous (ID 220254719)
IND_A_002 Anonymous (ID 220255639)
IND_A_003 Anonymous (ID 220455170)
IND_A_004 Anonymous (ID 220468582)
IND_A_005 Anonymous (ID 220666031)
IND_A_006 Anonymous (ID 220761834)
IND_A_007 Anonymous (ID 221116933)
IND_A_008 Anonymous (ID 221327371)
IND_A_009 Anonymous (ID 221408864)
IND_A_010 Anonymous (ID 221486735)
IND_A_011 Anonymous (ID 221517381)
IND_A_012 Anonymous (ID 222238882)
IND_A_013 Anonymous (ID 222501231)
IND_A_014 Anonymous (ID 223006242)
IND_A_015 Anonymous (ID 223011196)
IND_A_016 Anonymous (ID 223012303)
IND_A_017 Anonymous (ID 224457351)
IND_A_018 Anonymous (ID 224872402)
IND_A_019 Anonymous (ID 224928548)
IND_A_020 Anonymous (ID 225775277)
IND_A_021 Anonymous (ID 225816676)
IND_A_022 Anonymous (ID 226965352)
IND_A_023 Anonymous (ID 227584868)
IND_A_024 Anonymous (ID 227620803)
IND_A_025 Anonymous (ID 229164929)
IND_A_026 Anonymous (ID 229166744)
IND_A_027 Anonymous (ID 229167055)
IND_A_028 Anonymous (ID 229166194)
IND_A_029 Anonymous (ID 229167736)
IND_A_030 Anonymous (ID 229168435)
IND_A_031 Anonymous (ID 229166090)
IND_A_032 Anonymous (ID 229168343)
IND_A_033 Anonymous (ID 229166421)
IND_A_034 Anonymous (ID 229167710)
IND_A_035 Anonymous (ID 229167962)
IND_A_036 Anonymous (ID 229170796)
IND_A_037 Anonymous (ID 229169961)
IND_A_038 Anonymous (ID 229171240)
IND_A_039 Anonymous (ID 229171480)
IND_A_040 Anonymous (ID 229170072)
IND_A_041 Anonymous (ID 229166828)
IND_A_042 Anonymous (ID 229173063)
IND_A_043 Anonymous (ID 229166794)
IND_A_044 Anonymous (ID 229173548)
IND_A_045 Anonymous (ID 229175223)
IND_A_046 Anonymous (ID 229173369)
IND_A_047 Anonymous (ID 229175453)
IND_A_048 Anonymous (ID 229173360)
IND_A_049 Anonymous (ID 229178816)
IND_A_050 Anonymous (ID 229180797)
IND_A_051 Anonymous (ID 229180806)
IND_A_052 Anonymous (ID 229166298)
IND_A_053 Anonymous (ID 229183817)
IND_A_054 Anonymous (ID 229180798)
IND_A_055 Anonymous (ID 229181604)
IND_A_056 Anonymous (ID 229184021)
IND_A_057 Anonymous (ID 229185928)
IND_A_058 Anonymous (ID 229183606)
IND_A_059 Anonymous (ID 229186134)
IND_A_060 Anonymous (ID 229187043)
IND_A_061 Anonymous (ID 229191984)
IND_A_062 Anonymous (ID 229195991)
IND_A_063 Anonymous (ID 229193756)
IND_A_064 Anonymous (ID 229201172)
IND_A_065 Anonymous (ID 229196820)
IND_A_066 Anonymous (ID 229206156)
IND_A_067 Anonymous (ID 229212737)
IND_A_068 Anonymous (ID 229215895)
IND_A_069 Anonymous (ID 229216409)
IND_A_070 Anonymous (ID 229218542)
IND_A_071 Anonymous (ID 229219943)
IND_A_072 Anonymous (ID 229225970)
IND_A_073 Anonymous (ID 229227510)
IND_A_074 Anonymous (ID 229227496)
IND_A_075 Anonymous (ID 229231163)
IND_A_076 Anonymous (ID 229237273)
IND_A_077 Anonymous (ID 229169298)
IND_A_078 Anonymous (ID 229240623)
IND_A_079 Anonymous ID 229243979)
IND_A_080 Anonymous (ID 229248657)
IND_A_081 Anonymous (ID 229254606)
IND_A_082 Anonymous (ID 229256576)
IND_A_083 Anonymous (ID 229260703)
IND_A_084 Anonymous (ID 229276978)
IND_A_085 Anonymous (ID 229307740)
IND_A_086 Anonymous (ID 229321230)
IND_A_087 Anonymous (ID 229403536)
IND_A_088 Anonymous (ID 229449914)
IND_A_089 Anonymous (ID 229244651)
IND_A_090 Anonymous (ID 229475467)
IND_A_091 Anonymous (ID 229481654)
IND_A_092 Anonymous (ID 229511482)
IND_A_093 Anonymous (ID 229566100)
IND_A_094 Anonymous (ID 229602429)
IND_A_095 Anonymous (ID 229704501)
IND_A_096 Anonymous (ID 228126602)
IND_A_097 Anonymous (ID 224872402)
IND_A_098 Anonymous (ID 229166366)
IND_A_099 Anonymous (ID 220320780)
IND_A_100 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_101 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_102 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_103 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_104 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_105 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_106 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_A_107 Anonymous (non smart survey response)
IND_001 Brian Murray (ID 220245676)
IND_002 Christopher Mccormick (ID 220303571)
IND_003 Alex McCluskey (ID 220328194)
IND_004 Evelyn Hardie (ID 220329506)
IND_005 Steve Abbott (ID 220482072)
IND_006 Leonard McNeill (ID 220773243)
IND_007 Margaret Stewart (ID 220794673)
IND_008 Gaynor Allen (ID 221297566)
IND_009 Nicolas Dear (ID 221314051)
IND_010 Colin Mitchell (ID 221315041)
IND_011 Louise Argo (ID 221328882)
IND_012 David A Allan (ID 221336495)
IND_013 David Hannah (ID 221369695)
IND_014 Lynsey Claire Ainslie (ID 221387582)
IND_015 Jay Andrew (ID 221398183)
IND_016 John Duffy (ID 221544688)
IND_017 Dawn Skelton (ID 221750989)
IND_018 James Riley (ID 221327137)
IND_019 Marie Murray (ID 222224195)
IND_020 John Charles Pittendreigh (ID 222488762)
IND_021 Anne Hunter (ID 222615506)
IND_022 Steven Day (ID 223071250)
IND_023 Robin Woodburn (ID 223567358)
IND_024 Monica Lennon MSP (ID 223988060)
IND_025 Miss Elizabeth Gibson (ID 224784995)
IND_026 Philip n jones (ID 224792593)
IND_027 Pamela Ireland (ID 224800786)
IND_028 Jim McLean (ID 224871116)
IND_029 Tish Chalmers (ID 224868828)
IND_030 Sheila B. Waddell (ID 224947215)
IND_031 Francesca Brennan (ID 225427872)
ND_032 Allana Parker Dymock (ID 220567130)
IND_033 AnneMarie Kane (ID 225814786)
IND_034 Angela Wilson (ID 225994732)
IND_035 Brian Leishman (ID 226058482)
IND_036 Janet Henderson (ID226056260)
IND_037 Jonathan Erskine (ID 227919375)
IND_038 James Magnus Carmichael (ID 229033565)
IND_039 James Gibb Stenhouse (ID 229076622)
IND_040 Helen MacLean (ID 229122053)
IND_041 Lesley Murray (ID 229127480)
IND_042 Michael McGarvie (ID 229164368)
IND_043 Josh Hamilton (ID 229164854)
IND_044 Margaret Cook (ID 229165105)
IND_045 Gordon Miller (ID 229164416)
IND_046 Stephen Mcallister (ID 229165087)
IND_047 Barbara Harrison (ID 229164678)
IND_048 Bailie Gerry McGarvey (ID 229165202)
IND_049 Robert Falcon (ID 229166467)
IND_050 Kenneth Barlow (ID 229165358)
IND_051 Name not provided (ID 229166200)
IND_052 Richard Simpson (ID 229165557)
IND_053 Colm McConnell (ID 229167087)
IND_054 De Anne Hendry (ID 229167730)
IND_055 William Heggie (ID 229166028)
IND_056 Kors Allan (ID 229168819)
IND_057 Carmel Smith (ID 229167763)
IND_058 Dennis James Norrie (ID 229168955)
IND_059 Charles Craske (ID 229166604)
IND_060 John M McCormick (ID 229169672)
IND_061 Rhondda Geekie (ID 229169593)
IND_062 Name not provided (ID 229169469)
IND_063 John Scanlon (ID 229169299)
IND_064 Elaine Logue (ID 229168888)
IND_065 Sally Welham (ID 229169198)
IND_066 Emma Parker (ID 229171061)
IND_067 Catherine Shearer (ID 229171790)
IND_068 John O’Donnell (ID 229169207)
IND_069 Peter Rowberry (ID 229170546)
IND_070 Eleanor Casson (ID 229168936)
IND_071 Jeanette Wallace (ID 229171808)
IND_072 Margaret Ann Handy (ID 229171188)
IND_073 Gordon McClymont (ID 229172844)
IND_074 Gerry Convery (ID 229169466)
IND_075 Gordon Bruce (ID 229173424)
IND_076 Fiona Armour (ID 229172328)
IND_077 Hazel Wood (ID 229168984)
IND_078 Morag Sutherland Allan (ID 229173272)
IND_079 Emma Mary Davies (ID 229173110)
IND_080 Steve Brown (ID 229173087)
IND_081 Lisbeth Imrie (ID 229173982)
IND_082 Eileen Thomson (ID 229174991)
IND_083 Margaret H. Williams (ID 229175189)
IND_084 Ruth Phoenix (ID 229175843)
IND_085 Thomas Trevor Muir (ID 229175550)
IND_086 John Kelly (ID 229175398)
IND_087 Robert Leach (ID 229176883)
IND_088 Laurence Weir (ID 229176222)
IND_089 Shirley Nimmo (ID 229177726)
IND_090 Alan McLean (ID 229175895)
IND_091 Margaret Henderson (ID 229175364)
IND_092 Mylie ferguson (ID 229375053)
IND_093 Arthur John morgan (ID 229178132)
IND_094 David C King (ID 229176934)
IND_095 Catriona McCulloch (ID 229181023)
IND_096 Martyn Watkins (ID 229180529)
IND_097 Matt Duncan (ID 229178690)
IND_098 Gerard McElroy (ID 229181338)
IND_099 Evelyn TETT (ID 229183642)
IND_100 Alice Patricia Paine (ID 229181593)
IND_101 William Saunders Hughes (ID 229185110)
IND_102 Robert Kenny (ID 229186093)
IND_103 Karen Wilson (ID 229187682)
IND_104 John Leck (ID 229188999)
IND_105 Graham Haines (ID 229189778)
IND_106 Robert Tossnie (ID 229188280)
IND_107 William Lawrence Newman (ID 229186401)
IND_108 Erna Macfarlane (ID 229189815)
IND_109 Stanley Charles Cook (ID 229193035)
IND_110 Rosemary McKenna (ID 229193517)
IND_111 Kathleen Cameron (ID 229189723)
IND_112 Andrew Cochran (ID 229200847)
IND_113 John R Brown (ID 229203574)
IND_114 Helen leaver (ID 229209235)
IND_115 Alan Hunter (ID 229211574)
IND_116 Charles Logan Scott (ID 229213350)
IND_117 Michael Tierney (ID 229217097)
IND_118 Andrew Kevin Mulford (ID 229210945)
IND_119 Marie Lennon (ID 229219241)
IND_120 Anjam Ismail (ID 229223916)
IND_121 John England (ID 229226691)
IND_122 Matthew Bruce (ID 229226740)
IND_123 Janet Placido (ID 229227577)
IND_124 Pauline Kinsman (ID 229232265)
IND_125 Roddy Stuart (ID 229232603)
IND_126 Simon Taylor (ID 229235628)
IND_127 Donald D Bethel (ID 229236025)
IND_128 John Martin (ID 229237553)
IND_129 Christopher Peyton (ID 229237515)
IND_130 John Ormiston (ID 229246362)
IND_ 131 Samuel Todd (ID 229250283)
IND_132 Lawrie Morgan-Klein (ID 229253797)
IND_133 Barbara Orme (ID 229261317)
IND_134 Jason Paul Monk (ID 229274496)
IND_135 Matthew Shelley (ID 229275786)
IND_136 Edward Egan (ID 229281279)
IND_137 Michael Player (ID 229283022)
IND_138 Bob Stewart (ID 229290677)
IND_139 Andrew Dundas (ID 229283923)
IND_140 Keith Macdonald (ID 229297426)
IND_141 Stuart Divers (ID 229299145)
IND_142 Patio C. Cockburn (ID 229319670)
IND_143 Thomas William Hindmarsh (ID 229224062)
IND_144 Andrew Lynch Blaikie (ID 229335676)
IND_145 David Mark Williams (ID 229309028)
IND_146 Anthony Scoffield (ID 229243944)
IND_147 Margaret Gibb (ID 229298326)
IND_148 Mr Mauro Di Lullo (ID 229394232)
IND_149 Paul Holmes (ID 229419418)
IND_150 George Glendinning (ID 229421317)
IND_151 Allan Cameron (ID 229469631)
IND_152 Thomas Pickering (ID 229474429)
IND_153 Ian McAlpine (ID 229480664)
IND_154 Rynagh Flynn (ID 229479556)
IND_ 155 Dawn Macdonald (ID 229496304)
IND_156 Hazel Kennedy (ID 229529526)
IND_157 Peter Sheal (ID 229519667)
IND_158 Linda Jane Dorward (ID 229620721)
IND_159 Dr Mary Britton (ID 229650301)
IND_160 Wilma Brown (ID 229667766)
IND_161 Frank Brown (ID 229666419)
IND_162 Carolyn Maeve Crouchman (ID 229682832)
IND_163 Helen Biggins (ID 229683090)
IND_164 Janet Begg (ID 229690267)
IND_165 Mrs J Graham (ID 229691011)
IND_166 Moira Snowden (ID 229691591)
IND_167 S Brodie (ID 229695228)
IND_168 William Howat (ID 229697405 )
IND_169 Mr and Mrs-Harris (ID 229702507)
IND_170 Colin Ross (ID 229701224)
IND_171 Bill Martin (ID 229721002)
IND_172 Archie Dryburn (non smart survey)
IND_173 Jodie McVicar (non smart survey)
Eccles Court (non smart survey)
The following responses where received after the close of the consultation deadline and therefore were not included in the consultation summary document.